Feedback/Notes

 

Latest Activity

Stephen Brodie commented on Hope's group Imagine No Organized Religion
"WOTMQ: RMPS Demons Epilogue"
1 hour ago
Stephen Brodie commented on Adriana's group Freethought and Funny Bones
"Liberal Redneck - Arkansas Governor Mad at Self"
5 hours ago
Stephen Brodie commented on Adriana's group Freethought and Funny Bones
"That is funny Loren and I want to own one of those boxes. "
6 hours ago
Mrs.B commented on Adriana's group Freethought and Funny Bones
"That's funny!"
7 hours ago
Mrs.B commented on Hope's group Imagine No Organized Religion
"It's insulting."
8 hours ago
Mrs.B commented on Loren Miller's group Quote Of The Day
"And some of your governors demanding that our borders open!"
8 hours ago
Loren Miller commented on Adriana's group Freethought and Funny Bones
"I don't know whether or not any of you have ever run onto the "Useless Box" idea,…"
8 hours ago
Stephen Brodie commented on Hope's group Imagine No Organized Religion
""I love the poorly educated." Probably one of the most heinous remarks I've ever…"
10 hours ago
Loren Miller commented on Hope's group Imagine No Organized Religion
"Let's be real here. For the most part, "Godly Wisdom" = BULLSHIT, plain and simple.…"
14 hours ago
Loren Miller commented on Loren Miller's group Quote Of The Day
"... when people on the right talk about “freedom” what they actually mean is closer to…"
15 hours ago
Onyango Makagutu commented on Hope's group Imagine No Organized Religion
"Usually whenever i see someone talk of worldly and godly wisdom i wonder how do they access the…"
15 hours ago
Grinning Cat commented on Hope's group Imagine No Organized Religion
"Those scare quotes around "educated" made me think how some/many religions (and other…"
20 hours ago
Stephen Brodie commented on Loren Miller's group Quote Of The Day
"Nice one Joan, succinct and to the point as usual."
20 hours ago
Stephen Brodie commented on Richard Levison's photo
Thumbnail

Arcturian

"Richard, are you sure you are an atheist? Because you've got to expect some criticism for…"
20 hours ago
Joan Denoo commented on Loren Miller's group Quote Of The Day
"Terry, it is wonderful to see your post! I hope all is well with you.  I would reply to god,…"
21 hours ago
Stephen Brodie commented on Loren Miller's group Quote Of The Day
""Many orthodox people speak as though it were the business of sceptics to disprove received…"
21 hours ago
Terence Meaden commented on Loren Miller's group Quote Of The Day
"Very good Stephen, and I expect you know how Bertrand Russell responded if he found himself being…"
yesterday
Stephen Brodie commented on Loren Miller's group Quote Of The Day
"Apostate Prophet If I die, and Islam turns out to be true, and I stand before Allah, I will say…"
yesterday
Mrs.B commented on Hope's group Imagine No Organized Religion
"Yeah, & they don't want that to happen."
yesterday
Stephen Brodie commented on Hope's group Imagine No Organized Religion
"Ain't that the truth."
yesterday

We are a worldwide social network of freethinkers, atheists, agnostics and secular humanists.

Opinions of Robepierre, on forced eviction of religion from public life(de-christinization), the Vendee war(was it genocide?), The National Directory's sacking of Rome, 

1) Is Robespierre a character that should be respected or hated.

2) Were the tactics, and methods, of the Committee of Public Safety against christianity justifiable?

3)Was the extermination of Royalists and Catholic forces, and their supporters, in the Vendee War defendable

I struggle with with first one, as the brutality of the terror is undeniable, but his writings help me see just how extreme the circumstances are. All the monarchies of europe were united, the pope declared resistance to the cause of the republic the moral duty of the Catholics. Armies were marching from all sides, civil war was in the Vendee, in lyon. Food scarcity was driving panic, the Prussian general leading the blitz towards Paris was promising to raze Paris to the ground and punish the Parisians with terrible brutality. That said, he made the act of stating disagreement with him a capital offense, and denied people freedom of thought through the terror. 

2)I argue no, full stop.

3)Again, I dont know. French society is very polarized here, but I really know what my opinion here is.

Views: 93

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

though, the best argument against the argument of God. These godless radicals went to war with all of europe, and the muslim world, and the british empire, and won.

In my opinion, extermination and terror is never justifiable, and on top of that, it doesn't work. France is a very secular country, but religion and the religious have not been "exterminated". The Russian revolution also sought to purge society from religion, and it did not work, either. It is best to limit the power of organized religion, and specifically powerful religious organizations, and to promote critical thinking and learning; then religion will be relegated to a personal crutch and would be rendered toothless.

Now, the French Revolution perhaps could never had happened without horrific bloodshed, because the power of the monarchy was indeed absolute, and the masses lived under conditions of extreme under-privilege. And initially, there were backlashes and the French ended up with a monarchy again, under Bonaparte. It took a while for a truly secular nation to emerge.

I agree that the extreme violence against the noblity, rapes and despicable acts that were done and the "guillotine" aren't justifiable however great their motives were.

im inclined to support the guillotine as an execution method, given a fair and proper trial and convicted of a crime in which the death penalty is called for. The likes of Karla Homolka and Ted Bundy deserve the blade.

We had a very interesting and extensive discussion on the death penalty in our group last year, see here. I oppose the death penalty even for those who "deserve" it, for reasons explained in that discussion. May be worth reviving the discussion. It's a difficult and complex subject.

Well, the US civil war cost 250,000+ lives (in battle deaths only) vs. the French revolution's numbers (estimates vary between 16,000 and 40,000 deaths.)


Why isn't that also called Terror?

that's executed, it was part of the larger War of the First Coalition. Of which nearly 200,000 died in the Vendee alone.

RSS

© 2021   Created by Atheist Universe.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service