Latest Activity

Onyango Makagutu replied to Neal's discussion Radio Host wants to “shoot Hillary Clinton in the vagina” and says, “I want her to feel the pain” in the group Right Wing Whackos
3 hours ago
doone commented on Adriana's group Atheist Morality
5 hours ago
Shawn Close joined Jean Marie's group
8 hours ago
Michel commented on Julien's group The Music Box
9 hours ago
Hope commented on Hope's group Imagine No Religion
9 hours ago
doone replied to Dallas the Phallus's discussion Tamar Gendler: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Politics and Economics in the group Philosophers Stone
14 hours ago
doone commented on Michel's group The Daily Cosmos
14 hours ago
Dallas the Phallus added a discussion to the group Philosophers Stone
17 hours ago
Dallas the Phallus commented on Jean Marie's group DOG is my co-pilot
18 hours ago
Dallas the Phallus commented on Jean Marie's group DOG is my co-pilot
18 hours ago
Dallas the Phallus commented on Adriana's group Gender Blender
18 hours ago
National Atheist Party and Jessica Mokrzycki are now friends
23 hours ago
Jessica Mokrzycki commented on Adriana's group Freethought and Funny Bones
yesterday
Jessica Mokrzycki joined Adriana's group
yesterday
Jessica Mokrzycki commented on Sydni Moser's group Vegetarian and Vegan Atheists
yesterday
Jessica Mokrzycki joined Sydni Moser's group
yesterday

We are a worldwide social network of freethinkers, atheists, agnostics and secular humanists.

Do you think elderly people give off a distinctive scent? And I'm not talking about incontinent elderly folks, I'm talking about the smell of old healthy folks with good hygiene habits. I always thought my grandmother smelled in a peculiar way when I was a teenager. Later in life, I thought my mother, who was in her 80s by then, also had developed a sweetish, not unpleasant smell at all, but very distinctively an old person's smell. Well, science has now proven that younger folks can tell distinguish the scent of older people from that of younger people, in a statistically significant way, in a blind test involving pads worn under the armpits during sleep, for 5 consecutive nights. The test subjects however, did not describe the smell as unpleasant but rather when compared with the "musk" of younger people, especially men, they found the old person's smell to be the least unpleasant. We associate the goodness or badness of smells with different contexts, so perhaps this is why young people describe old people's smell as unpleasant when asked (perhaps they associate it with nursing homes, or declining strength, etc.), but out of context, without knowing who the smell came from, they did not find it unpleasant.Is there an evolutionary reason for the ability to discern the age of a person by smell? It's not clear but some speculate that in ancient times, those who got to be old were the strongest and healthiest, and perhaps that increased their desirability as males. That seems a long stretch to me. It could simply be that old people sweat less and produce less testosterone, therefore the "musky" smell diminishes.

Smells Like Old Spirit

on 30 May 2012, 5:10 PM | 8 Comments

sn-smell.jpg

The nose knows. Older folks give off a characteristic odor, which "blind sniff testers" found less intense and less unpleasant than the smell of younger people.
Credit: Thinkstock
 

Older folks give off a characteristic scent that's independent of race, creed, or diet. The Japanese even have a name for it: kareishu. Most people say they find the smell disagreeable, typically describing it as "stinky-sweet." But in a new study, participants in a "blind sniff test" found the body odor of older people less intense and more pleasant than that of the young or middle-aged.

Sensory neuroscientist Johan Lundström has been familiar with old-person scent since his childhood in Sweden, where he sometimes accompanied his mother to her job at a nursing home. Decades later, as the head of his own lab at the Monell Chemical Senses Center in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, he gave a talk at another nursing home. "The same smell hit me again," he says. Lundström wondered if there really are specific age-related odors that the human sense of smell can detect. Although research shows that animals can distinguish the ages of other animals based on their odor, no comparable studies had been done in humans.

So Lundström and colleagues recruited 20 men and 21 women between the ages of 20 and 30 to be sniffers. All were healthy nonsmokers who didn't take drugs or medications. Meanwhile, a group of "donors" who were young (20 to 30 years old), middle age (45 to 55 years old), and old (75 to 95 years old) went to bed for five consecutive nights wearing T-shirts with absorbent pads sewn into the armpits. To make sure they gave off only their natural scent, the donors washed their hair and bodies with odorless shampoos and soap before going to bed each night. They also refrained from smoking, drinking alcohol, or eating spicy food.

The volunteers sniffed the pads worn by the variously aged donors and grouped the smells by age. They classified the smells of the older donors with 12% greater acc..., the researchers report online today in PLoS ONE.

Read the rest here.

Tags: age, neuroscience, smell

Views: 50

Replies to This Discussion

The original abstract:

The Smell of Age: Perception and Discrimination of Body Odors of Different Ages

Susanna Mitro1,2, Amy R. Gordon1,3, Mats J. Olsson3, Johan N. Lundström1,3,4*

1 Monell Chemical Senses Center, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States of America, 2 Swarthmore College, Swarthmore, Pennsylvania, United States of America, 3 Section of Psychology, Dept. Clinical Neuroscience, Karolinska Institute, Stockholm, Sweden, 4 Department of Psychology, University of Pennsylvania, Pennsylvania, United States of America

Abstract Top

Our natural body odor goes through several stages of age-dependent changes in chemical composition as we grow older. Similar changes have been reported for several animal species and are thought to facilitate age discrimination of an individual based on body odors, alone. We sought to determine whether humans are able to discriminate between body odor of humans of different ages. Body odors were sampled from three distinct age groups: Young (20–30 years old), Middle-age (45–55), and Old-age (75–95) individuals. Perceptual ratings and age discrimination performance were assessed in 41 young participants. There were significant differences in ratings of both intensity and pleasantness, where body odors from the Old-age group were rated as less intense and less unpleasant than body odors originating from Young and Middle-age donors. Participants were able to discriminate between age categories, with body odor from Old-age donors mediating the effect also after removing variance explained by intensity differences. Similarly, participants were able to correctly assign age labels to body odors originating from Old-age donors but not to body odors originating from other age groups. This experiment suggests that, akin to other animals, humans are able to discriminate age based on body odor alone and that this effect is mediated mainly by body odors emitted by individuals of old age.

I wonder how much dietary changes in elderly people effects their odor.

Commonly reported changes in diet of the elderly included less frequent intake of red meat, eggs, fried and fatty foods and more frequent intake of vegetables, chicken and fish, as well as changes towards use of polyunsaturated margarine, no longer eating the fat on meat and no longer presoaking vegetables in water before cooking. Of concern was a change in some subjects to a less frequent consumption of milk or other dairy products.

It's possible, but the fact that the "old-age" odor discrimination is cross-cultural, it would suggest that there is something else besides diet. The article reports that there are two compounds produced by the skin's glands that increase with age:

To date, two chemically-related compounds have been confirmed to vary with age in humans: nonenal [32] and nonanal [33]. Both compounds increase with age, particularly older individuals, who exhibit a sharp increase in concentration

It would be easy, and super-interesting, to carry out studies based on diet, for example compare vegans to meat eaters, fish eaters to non-fish eaters, etc. For that one would have to compare men (or woman) of the same age, in order to control for age related effects and just focus on diet.

There are foods (or stuff we consume) that obviously change the smell of a person's skin, like too much alcohol, for example. Usually you can smell it on the person the day after an alcohol binge.


The only time I've heard the term "Old persons smell" was to describe the odor of convalescent homes. That smell doesn't have anything to do with this study. This study attempted to restrict diet, but some Old-age donors used regular medication. It is has been speculated that polymorphonuclear leukocytes [46], a type of white blood cells that demonstrate an age-dependent increase in humans, might be a potential biomarker worth exploring in future studies. 

Although considerable efforts were made to control the collection of body odors within a donor’s home (including detailed t-shirt handling instructions, dietary restrictions, personal hygiene regulations, etc.), differences in lifestyle, living environment, and other factors outside our control might still contribute to the demonstrated age discrimination. We believe, however, that the impact of these variables is minor and counteracted by the use of supra-donors, which minimize any non-age-dependent factors not presented in a majority of the donors. Similarly, due to the scarcity of Old-age body odor donors who were not using regulated pharmaceutical compounds, some individuals in the Old-age donor group did use regular medication. Although none of the medications are known to affect body odor composition, and although there was no difference in perceptual ratings of body odors from individuals using medication and those not using medication, it is still conceivable that this age-dependent discrimination, driven by the Old-age odors, is to some extent mediated by the metabolites of pharmaceutical compounds secreted into the body odors sampled from those elderly donors.

Being the very first study to assess the ability of human participants to determine age from body odors, we focused on a very narrow research question and much remains to be explored. Only young experimental participants were included in this study. It is very much conceivable that the effects demonstrated in this study displays a double age-dependent effect, i.e. that age of the rater has an impact on the ability to determine the age of the body odor donor. Moreover, great care was taken to avoid contamination of exogenous odors, thus lowering the ecological validity of the study. Of interest would be to explore what impact natural masking with hygiene product would have on the demonstrated results.

We can at this point only speculate as to what the potential biological mechanisms could be. It is has been speculated that polymorphonuclear leukocytes [46], a type of white blood cells that demonstrate an age-dependent increase in humans, might be a potential biomarker worth exploring in future studies. 

Previous studies exploring potential biomarkers of age in human and animal body odors have not been conclusive and often fail to take very old age individuals into account. Nevertheless, identifying potential biomarkers is of great interest and would assist in isolating the underlying biological mechanisms mediating and developing these effects.

In conclusion, these data suggest that, akin to other animals, humans are able to discriminate old individuals from younger individuals based on body odor. The modest effects suggest a limited impact on our everyday interactions but does support previous reports of a unique ‘old person odor’. Further experimental work is clearly warranted to determine the mechanism and function of body odor-dependent age discrimination.

RSS

© 2013   Created by Atheist Universe.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service