Latest Activity

National Atheist Party and Jessica Mokrzycki are now friends
1 hour ago
Jessica Mokrzycki commented on Adriana's group Freethought and Funny Bones
4 hours ago
Jessica Mokrzycki joined Adriana's group
4 hours ago
Jessica Mokrzycki commented on Sydni Moser's group Vegetarian and Vegan Atheists
4 hours ago
Jessica Mokrzycki joined Sydni Moser's group
4 hours ago
Jessica Mokrzycki left a comment for Neal
4 hours ago
Jessica Mokrzycki posted photos
4 hours ago
Jessica Mokrzycki updated their profile
4 hours ago
Jessica Mokrzycki commented on Neal's video
5 hours ago
Neal left a comment for Jessica Mokrzycki
5 hours ago
Neal commented on Jessica Mokrzycki's status
5 hours ago
Bo Fowler posted a status
"Just added a new very short story to my blog. Hope you like it. http://ning.it/11MX1PC"
5 hours ago
Jessica Mokrzycki posted videos
5 hours ago
Jessica Mokrzycki posted a status
"My first day here! Wow..what an awesome site...It's like fb for atheists and free thinkers! :)"
6 hours ago
Jessica Mokrzycki left a comment for Neal
6 hours ago
Jessica Mokrzycki and Neal are now friends
6 hours ago

We are a worldwide social network of freethinkers, atheists, agnostics and secular humanists.

In case you guys want to know how DNA testing is done to confirm the identity of a person, Christie Wilcox from the blog Observation of a Nerd has an excellent post, including good graphics. There are different ways to use DNA for identification purposes but she explains one of the most tried and true methods in a very clear fashion; she also very wisely describes how long it takes to carry out each of the steps in the process. Identification always involves comparison with a relative's DNA (unless there is a previous DNA sample from the person in question) and in Bin Laden's case, his sister had died at a Boston hospital and a sample of tissue had been used for DNA extraction. Christie speculates that perhaps Bin Laden had been dead for a day or two and the US government waited for the results of the DNA test before making the announcement.

 

How do you ID a dead Osama anyway?

Posted on: May 1, 2011 9:13 PM, by Christie Wilcox

Osama Bin Laden is dead. At least, that's what we've been told, and I tend to believe such things.

But how do they know it's him? Well, they have the visual evidence and the body, for one. But to be certain it's not a look-a-like, the government has taken steps above and beyond to make sure they've got who they think they have: DNA analysis.

Now, I'm not entirely sure what DNA analysis has been done, but I can say this for certain - whatever method they used could be completed in a matter of hours given a lab ready to go and focused solely on this. Using commonplace PCR methods - which, for the record, is what I use in my lab every day - Bin Laden could easily be ID'd faster than you'd think. Heck, I can get DNA from a fish and turn it into sequences or genotypes in 24 hours, so I think the US government can work faster than me when time is of the essence. Allow let me explain how they could do it so quickly.

Step 1. Extract DNA
If they've got his body, then they've got enough DNA to run a billion or two genetic tests. It takes extremely little DNA to run genetic tests - on the order of single cells. So having even a 1 mm square piece of flesh would provide more DNA than they would even have use for. Extraction takes very little time. All you need to do it place the cells/tissue in some kind of solution that will break up the cell's membranes, thus liberating the DNA from the nucleus without damaging the DNA too much. There are hundreds of extraction kits and protocols. I don't know what the gov't extraction policy is, but the Arkansas State Crime Lab just uses sodium hydroxide and hydrochloric acid to extract DNA from their samples (which, btw, is how I get DNA from my fish samples, too). For example, this is their protocol for buccal punches (a.k.a. cheek tissue):

  1. Place 52 μl of 0.01 M NAOH in each well with 2.0 mm of tissue.
  2. Incubate samples at 65°C for 10 minutes.
  3. Add 10 μl of 0.1 M Tris HCl (pH 7.3).
  4. Mix.
  5. Let stand for 5 minutes.
  6. Samples are now ready for amplification

TOTAL TIME: 15 min

Step 2: Amplify Identifying DNA Sequences
Once you have DNA, you're ready to ID your suspect. While there have been a few methods used in the past, the onset of Polymerase Chain Reaction, or PCR technology, has made looking at parts of a genome pretty darn quick and easy.

The namesake of PCR, polymerase, is a very special enzyme that cells use to duplicate DNA. Polymerases are found in all creatures because we all must, at some point, have cells divide to grow and reproduce. When our cells divide, we have to make two copies of our genome - one for each new cell. To do this, our cells unwind the DNA, spread apart the two matching strands, then use each as templates to make two new strands. Polymerases are the enzymes that actually do that - they attach to single strands of DNA and grab matching nucleotides to create the other half of the strand.

PCR was invented in the 1980s and takes advantage of how our DNA reacts to temperature. At lower temperatures, like in our bodies, DNA sticks to it's complementary half and forms a tight helix. But as you turn up the heat, our DNA denatures - that is, it unwinds and each half of the helix separates. We can't use our own cell's polymerases for PCR because they can't stand that kind of heat. Instead, we've borrowed an enzyme from a particularly heat-tolerant bacteria to do the job for us.

 

Read the rest here.

Tags: Bin Laden, DNA, PCR, identification

Views: 9

Replies to This Discussion

Particularly the death of Bin Laden brings the pertinence of this quote so well:  "Science flies you to the moon. Religion flies you into buildings."
Thanks, this was very informative.
Once confirmed, they buried his body at sea. I was surprised by that at first.
I think it's to avoid having a fixed site where admirers can go on pilgrimage.
Followers can reach paradise much faster (and without much colateral damage) if they go pay their respect at the bottom of the sea.
I am wondering if they buried the others killed in the compound at sea.  I've not heard it mentioned on the news.

This article argues the DNA analysis was not done in the field; but at a lab at a command center. As smeone who does DNA analysis routinely, I concur.

Did Rapid DNA Analysis Verify Osama Bin Laden's Death?

A few years ago, I worked as a Writing Department Intern for C.S.I. Crime Scene Investigation and C.S.I. New York. Seeing producers, writers and real C.S.I.s collaboratively bring a story from pitch to beatsheat was intoxicating. Research was meticulous. Science served as mascot, foundation and muse.

Despite the show's dedication to rigorous research, its ultimate success had a lot to do with the fact that the creators didn't try to replicate a day in the life of a C.S.I. Team or a forensic DNA lab. The actual C.S.I. Investigators don't go from the crime scene to the lab. The forensic analysis is done by trained lab techs. What would those award winning "C.S.I. Shots" be without charismatic stars in starch white lab jackets peering through microscopes, though?

A photo of the real and considerably less glamorous Las Vegas C.S.I. Team taped to the refrigerator was one of many many testaments to the team's awareness of the conscious discrepancy between factual and actual. Another was the timing. Turnaround time for DNA analysis is not instantaneous. Enter the episodic Hollywood procedural fiat clause. Two beats later the DNA is verified.

The evening of May 1st 2011, American audiences were riveted to their computers and television screens watching the most expensive criminal investigations in history unfold. As would be expected, scientists, journalists and laypeople are now scrutinizing the verification details with the fundamental question, "How do we know it was Bin Laden?"

Real forensic science labs may not incorporate the Hollywood fiat into their practices. An E.C. funded portable rapid DNA test, developed at University of Arizona Phoenix, however might.

Professor Frederic Zenhausern at the Center for Applied Nanobioscience and Medicine said that the technology he is developing through the UK Forensic Science Service "is currently under validation by several crime labs in the UK, Germany, Austria and the Netherlands."

Could those dots connect all the way to Pakistan? Not likely.

Zenhausern reiterated that, "there is no rapid DNA system available for a portable deployment in such a mission yet." The system his team is developing is the "only one reported to be close to such requirements," however, it is "not validated yet."

Exciting as it may be to speculate, "it is unlikely USG (United States Government) used such a system at the site. More likely they transported the samples (and/or body) to a command center" equipped with the "instrumentation and bench space to accommodate the lab equipment."

Whereas a low profile DNA case would be "processed with the conventional lab-bench techniques" that could "take up to 10-14 days," an extraordinary case, such as the most expensive manhunt in history, "could be performed in less than 24 hours" through an integrated system that has a "turnaround time of less than 2 hours."

Zenhausern speculates that,"Osama Bin Laden’s DNA analysis may have been performed through cross-validation of processing at different USG labs...possibly located at some strategic and local command centers equipped with conventional and high quality STR (Short Tandem Repeat) profiling platform technologies."

Given the highly orchestrated nature of the operation, surrounding military bases –already prepared with on-site facilities for identifying soldiers-- could have been alerted ahead of time, but they still needed to travel there. This explains the gap between the 3:50 pm EST ID confirmation and The White House's 10:30 pm DNA verified announcement.

"In a near future, rapid DNA testing using a single piece of portable equipment will improve the cycle time, mobility and possibly reduce some of the cost of the analysis while providing a much simpler user interface." Zenhausern said, positing that "comparative matches may have been done from previously collected samples from skin, hair, fingerprint or any other object Bin Laden may have been touching (e.g. cup) and/or from samples collected from family members."

It won't be long before the rapid technology being developed will be a legitimate DNA verification process. Right now, however, it's still a Hollywood thing.

 

RSS

© 2013   Created by Atheist Universe.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service