Latest Activity

We are a worldwide social network of freethinkers, atheists, agnostics and secular humanists.


Chronicling Mitt's Mendacity, Vol. XIV

  -  

Getty Images

Campaigning in Ohio yesterday, Mitt Romney told supporters, without smirking or sounding sarcastic, "If I'm president of the United States, with your help, I will tell the truth."

Ordinarily, those seeking national leadership positions don't vow to tell the truth if others help them, but since I am nothing if not helpful, I thought I might give the presumptive Republican presidential nominee a few examples of instances in which he fell short of honesty this week.

Indeed, if Romney intends to "tell the truth," he can start by reading the 14th installment of my weekly series, chronicling Mitt's mendacity.

1. Speaking to the NRA, Romney said, "The Obama administration has decided that it has the power to mandate what Catholic charities, schools, and hospitals must cover in their insurance plans.... Here we are, just getting started with Obamacare, and the federal government is already dictating to religious groups on matters of doctrine and conscience."

In Massachusetts' governor for one term, Romney took the same position Obama has adopted. He somehow forgot to mention this.

2. Romney also told the NRA audience, "We need a president who will enforce current laws, not create new ones that only serve to burden lawful gun owners. President Obama has not, I will."

The grammar in this sentence makes it hard to understand, but the implication seems to be that Obama has created new restrictions on gun laws. That's a lie.

3. Romney also claims to be a "lifetime" member of the NRA.

In reality, Romney used to oppose the NRA, but became a "lifetime" member fairly recently by buying the honor from the group.

4. Romney also shared this interesting anecdote: "Mike and Chantell Sackett have seen firsthand how the Obama government interferes with personal freedom. They run a small business in Idaho. They saved enough money to buy a piece of property and build a home. But days after they broke ground, an EPA regulator told them to stop digging. The EPA said they were building on a wetland. But the Sackett's property isn't on the wetlands register. It sits in a residential area. Nevertheless, the EPA wouldn't even let them appeal the decision. Fortunately, the Constitution confronted the Obama administration: the Supreme Court ruled unanimously for the Sacketts and against the Obama EPA."

That's a fascinating story, but it was the Bush/Cheney EPA that the Sackett family was fighting.

5. In the same speech, Romney said, "[Obama] told the Russian president last month when he thought no one else was listening, after his re-election he'll have a lot more, quote, 'flexibility' to do what he wants."

That's not what Obama said.

6. Romney concluded, "We'll stop the days of apologizing for success at home and never again apologize for America abroad."

This is a lie Romney repeats so often, it raises real concerns about his character.

7. Romney told ABC's Diane Sawyer, "92% -- 93% of the jobs lost have been lost by women during this president's term."

This is a ridiculous lie.

8. Trying to justify his secrecy on tax returns, Mitt Romney told CNBC, "John Kerry released two years of taxes."

That's not true.

9. Romney also told CNBC about the Buffett Rule, "[T]hey couldn't get it through their own Democratic Senate."

The Buffett Rule enjoyed the support of a majority of the Senate, but it died because of a Republican filibuster. "They" could have gotten it through the Senate if the bill was given an up-or-down vote.

10. The Romney campaign told NBC News this week that the former governor "never solicited" Ted Nugent's endorsement.

There's clear evidence pointing in the exact opposite direction.

11. On tax policy, Romney argued this week, "I'm going to keep the burden on the upper-income people the same as it is today."

That's extremely misleading -- Romney intends to give the rich a massive tax cut. The "burden" may not shift because he intends to cut taxes across the board, but the claim makes it seem as if "upper-income people" won't see a change in their taxes, when in fact Romney intends to give them another huge break. (Thanks to reader V.S. for the tip on this one.)

12. In Charlotte, Romney said of the president and the upcoming Democratic convention, "He's not going to want to remind anyone of Greece because he's put us on a road to become more like Greece."

Obama hasn't put us on a road to become more like Greece. (Nor has Bush, who's still largely responsible for today's deficits.)

13. In the same speech, Romney said Obama "is on track to add almost as much public debt to this country as all the prior presidents combined."

That's a lie.

14. Romney also said in the same speech that Bush added "far less" to the national debt than Obama.

That's not even close to being true.

15. In the same speech, Romney said Obama is "first president in modern history, in any history, to cut Medicare by $500 billion."

Romney has said this countless times, but it doesn't change the fact that it's not true.

16. Romney claimed on Thursday that Obama has placed "three times" as many regulatory burdens on the private second as Bush did.

That's the opposite of the truth.

17. In Ohio yesterday, Romney argued, "[Obama] said that if we let him borrow $787 billion, he would unemployment below 8%."

There is no universe in which this claim is true.

18. In the same speech, Romney said Obama "has not created more jobs for the American people."

I know Romney's busy running for president, but he should at least try to keep up with current events.

19. Romney, in the same speech, shared one of his new favorite talking points: "The number of new businesses started per year is down 100,000 a year under the Obama term."

Actually, for those who take facts seriously, just last year, more than 540,000 new businesses were started each month -- which is well above the levels seen before the Great Recession began.

20. The Romney campaign argued this week that Kris Kobach, Romney's controversial adviser on immigration policy, is a "supporter," not an "adviser."

In reality, Kobach is still very much an adviser to Romney and his team.

21. The Romney campaign also said yesterday that the former governor never said Arizona's anti-immigrant law is a "model" for the nation.

Romney absolutely said Arizona's anti-immigrant law is a "model" for the nation.

The Obama campaign, by the way, seems well aware of the fact that Romney lies with unnerving frequency, but seems reluctant to say so in harsh terms, fearing media and voter pushback. Instead, as of yesterday, Team Obama is resorting to an interesting euphemism: "Why does [Romney] have such an aversion to the truth?"

Whether the political mainstream is comfortable using the word "lie" or not, that question seems increasingly unavoidable.

Previous editions of Chronicling Mitt's Mendacity: Vol. IIIIIIIVVVIVIIVIIIIXXXIXIIXIII.

Tags: -, Confused, Just, Liar, Mitt, Romney, Serial, or

Views: 25

Replies to This Discussion

Mitt Romney Blames Obama For Bad Economy At Factory That Was Shutte...

Romney's event yesterday

Yesterday, presumed GOP nominee Mitt Romney made a major campaign stop at the shuttered factory where then-candidate Obama spoke in 2008. The National Gypsum plant has since closed, and Romney said that fact “underscores the failureof this president’s policies with regards to getting the economy working again.”

But Romney’s implication that the plant’s closing is a result of Obama’s economic policies is undercut by the fact that the plant closed before Obama took office. The factory closed in June 2008, when George W. Bush was still president.

This isn’t the first time the Romney campaign has tried to blame Obama for something that happened under his predecessor. The campaign’s central piece of evidence in arguing that Obama has been bad for women — that 92 percent of job losses under Obama were from women — counts job losses that occurred from the beginning of January 2009, even though Obama wasn’t sworn in until the end of that month.

 Journalism.org:
HOW THE MEDIA COVERED THE 2012 PRIMARY CAMPAIGN  —  LESS HORSE RACE THAN 2008  —  By Tom Rosenstiel, Mark Jurkowitz and Tricia Sartor of PEJ  —  Mitt Romney needed 15 weeks once the primary contests began to gain a secure hold over his party's nomination for president.
 Paul Krugman / New York Times:
The Amnesia Candidate  —  Just how stupid does Mitt Romney think we are?  If you've been following his campaign from the beginning, that's a question you have probably asked many times.  —  But the question was raised with particular force last week, when Mr. Romney tried …


Chronicling Mitt's Mendacity, Vol. XVI

  -  

Getty Images

After finally wrapping up his strange presidential campaign this week, Newt Gingrich talked to Wolf Blitzer about his support for his former rival, Mitt Romney. The CNN host asked, "Do you still believe Romney is a liar?"

Gingrich replied, in reference to the presidential candidate he now supports, "The governor said things at times that weren't true." Pressed further on whether that means Romney's a liar, Gingrich changed the subject.

It's generally not a good sign when high-profile supporters of a candidate hedge on whether the candidate is an honest person, but then again, the presumptive Republican nominee is not like most candidates. To appreciate the scope of Romney's distortions, consider the 16th installment of my weekly series, chronicling Mitt's mendacity.

1. In a speech in Ohio, Romney referred to the Bush/Cheney era as "before the recession."

The recession began in late 2007, more than a year before President Obama's inauguration. The economy crashed in September 2008, four months before Obama took office. Someone who claims an expertise in economic policy probably ought to know that.

2. In the same speech, Romney summarized his message to young people: "[I]t's so critical, in my view, for you to consider what's in the best interest of not just yourself, but of America, over the coming century, and it is to stop the excessive overspending."

Annual domestic spending is already on track to become the smallest share of the economy since Dwight Eisenhower's administration.

3. Romney acknowledged that President "inherited" the recession, but added that Obama "didn't make it better."

That's plainly false.

4. In the same speech, Romney said once "Obamacare" is implemented, "government at all levels" will "consume" 50% of the American economy.

David Corn explains today that this is Romney's arguably "biggest fib," which falls "somewhere between 'ridiculous' and 'stupid.'"

5. Also from that speech, Romney said Obama's record includes "the first trillion deficit in history."

That's a blatant lie -- the day Obama was inaugurated, there was a $1.3 trillion deficit Bush had left for him to clean up.

6. In the same remarks, Romney said, "We're on track to become Greece."

No, we're not.

7. The Romney campaign again claimed "more than 92%" of the jobs lost since Obama took office are women.

This still is a ridiculous lie.

8. The Romney campaign added, "The fact is, what we have now is the U.S. economy is a hostile workplace for women under President Obama because it's harder to get a job."

That's absurdly untrue, too.

9. In New Hampshire, Romney said Obama is "focused on taking away from those who have the least."

That's blatantly untrue in an ironic sort of way. Romney's tax plan calls for higher taxes on those at the lowest end of the income scale. He also intends to cut food stamps, Medicaid, and educational spending, which benefit those who have the least.

10. Romney also vowed, "I want to help the poor."

First, see #9. Second, he specifically said earlier this year, "I'm not very concerned about the poor."

11. Romney told Charlie Rose that the president has launched an "attack on small businesses."

In reality, Obama has cut taxes on small businesses (several times), eased the process that allows small businesses to be created, and streamlined the patent process.

12. The Romney campaign argued this week that the former governor's position on the auto-industry rescue "was exactly what President Obama followed," adding, "The only economic success that President Obama has had is because he followed Mitt Romney's advice."

Romney condemned Obama's efforts on the industry rescue repeatedly, including throughout the GOP primaries. He can't oppose the policy and take credit for the policy at the same time, at least not if he's being honest.

13. Romney said regulations under Obama are duplicating "like proverbial rabbits."

It's a subjective question, I suppose, but at a minimum, this is deeply misleading. The truth is, Obama approved fewer regulations than George W. Bush did over a comparable period.

14. The Romney campaign this week claimed President Obama "delivered" the controversy over GSA over-spending at a Las Vegas conference.

The Obama administration launched the investigation that uncovered the wrongdoing, and GSA's reckless conference spending began during the Bush era.

15. In a speech in Virginia yesterday, Romney blamed "card check" for making things "tougher" on businesses.

Card check didn't pass, so it's impossible for Romney's argument to be true.

16. In the same speech, Romney said Obama has "added about 150,000 government workers."

That's the opposite of reality, and reflects an unnerving ignorance about job policy.

17. Romney, at the same event, said raising the top marginal income tax rate would force small businesses to "cut back" and not "hire more."

This is one of those zombie lies that never goes away, but it's still not true.

18. Romney went on to condemn Obama for "shutting down" a "wonderful" school voucher program in the District of Columbia.

Obama didn't shut down the school voucher program in the District of Columbia. It still exists.

At one of his events this week, Romney, in apparent reference to the president's eloquence on the stump, told voters, "[A]s you look at the campaign of 2012, you're gonna hear a lot of words, but you're going to have an opportunity to also look behind the words at the facts.... Words are easily malleable but facts, they're stubborn."

Yes, governor, they are.

Previous editions of Chronicling Mitt's Mendacity: Vol. IIIIIIIVVVIVIIVIIIIXXXIXII,XIIIXIVXV

 Brian Beutler / tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com:
TPMDC  —  Awkward!  Republicans Who Opposed Auto Bailout Stumped By Romney Claiming Credit For It  —  As long as Mitt Romney publicly claims credit for the auto industry's recovery, he's going to put his fellow Republicans on Capitol Hill in an awkward position.
RELATED:


Chronicling Mitt's Mendacity, Vol. XVIII

  -  

Getty Images

Back in February, Paul Krugmanargued that Mitt Romney is "running a campaign of almost pathological dishonesty." Was this an intemperate analysis? Perhaps. Three months later, does it seem fair? Put it this way: take a look at the 18th installment of my weekly series, chronicling Mitt's mendacity.

1. Romney promised in a speech this week, "I will lead us out of this debt and spending inferno."

Given that his stated agenda would add trillions to the debt, and Romney refuses to say how he'd pay for his tax cuts and increased Defense spending, the claim seems pretty misleading.

2. Romney claimed in the same speech that Obama has "bailed out the public-sector."

I really wish that were true. It's not.

3. Romney also argued that Obama has "added almost as much debt as all the prior presidents combined."

That's not even close to being true.

4. Romney insisted that the national debt is responsible for "the most tepid recovery in modern history."

That's ridiculously false. If the debt were holding back the economy, we'd have high interest rates and high inflation. We have the opposite.

5. Romney also said the national debt is the reason "half of the kids graduating from college can't find a job that uses their skills."

There is no universe in which this is true (or really, even coherent).

6. On the Recovery Act, Romney said, "President Obama started out with a near trillion-dollar stimulus package -- the biggest, most careless one-time expenditure by the federal government in history. And remember this: the stimulus wasn't just wasted -- it was borrowed and wasted."

The Recovery Act rescued the economy. Romney doesn't have to like it, but he shouldn't lie about it.

7. Romney added, equating the debt with a prairie fire, Obama "fed the fire. He has spent more and borrowed more."

That's false, too.

8. Referencing the Affordable Care Act, Romney argued, "Then there was Obamacare. Even now nobody knows what it will actually cost."

"Nobody" except the Congressional Budget Office, the Office of Management and Budget, and every budget expert with access to a calculator.

9. Romney argued that the Affordable Care Act is a "massive, European-style entitlement."

No, it's not. Most of Europe has socialized or government-run health care systems. Obamacare doesn't resemble France; it resembles Massachusetts' Romneycare.

10. Romney also insisted Americans "can't afford" the health-care reform law.

Actually, the ACA lowers the deficit by hundreds of billions of dollars.

11. Romney argued, "When you add up his policies, this president has increased the national debt by five trillion dollars."

That's an obvious lie. It's not Obama's policies that are driving the debt.

12. Romney claimed that more of the economy is being "absorbed ... into government."

That's the opposite of the truth.

13. Romney argued, "Medicare and Social Security are also easy to demagogue, and I expect the president to continue doing that in this campaign."

Romney has said several hundred times that Obama cut $500 billion from Medicare and is the only president to ever cut Medicare benefits. Neither is true, but both are excellent examples of demagoguery.

14. On gay adoption, Romney said "all states but one allow gay adoption."

That's not even close to being true.

15. The Romney campaign said of Obama, "He promised he would cut the debt, and he has not done that."

Obama made no such promise. He promised to cut the deficit, not the debt -- presidential campaigns really should know the difference if it's going to talk about these issues -- and Obama has cut the deficit.

16. Romney said of his controversial private-sector background, "We were able to help create over 100,000 jobs."

This is one of the more important lies Romney will tell this year.

17. On the president's watch, about 100,000 jobs were lost in the auto industry and auto dealers and auto manufacturers, so he's hardly one to point a finger."

First, the comparison is absurd. Second, the claim about the auto industry is demonstrably ridiculous.

18. On GST Steel, Romney said of his critics, "They said, 'Oh, gosh, Governor Romney at Bain Capital closed down a steel factory.' But their problem, of course, is that the steel factory closed down two years after I left Bain Capital. I was no longer there, so that's hardly something which is on my watch."

Actually, Romney retained full, sole ownership of the firm at the time GST collapsed.

19. Romney's campaign said yesterday that it's "clear" that the Obama campaign "is running a campaign of character assassination."

Asked for an example of Obama engaging in character assassination, the Romney campaign so far hasn't come up with anything.

I continue to think about something Fox News' Brit Hume said a few months ago. Reflecting on Romney's flip-flops, said, "You're only allowed a certain number of flips before people begin to doubt your character."

I'm curious -- is Romney also allowed a certain number of falsehoods before people begin to doubt his character? And if so, what is that number?

Previous editions of Chronicling Mitt's Mendacity: Vol. IIIIIIIVVVIVIIVIIIIXXXIXII,XIIIXIVXVXVIXVII


Chronicling Mitt's Mendacity, Vol. XIX

  -  

Getty Images

Campaigning in Iowa yesterday, President Obama reflected on some of Mitt Romney's recent speeches, including last week's remarks in Iowa. "I know Governor Romney came to Des Moines last week; warned about a 'prairie fire of debt,'" Obama said. "But he left out some facts. His speech was more like a cow pie of distortion. I don't know whose record he twisted the most -- mine or his."

It was a rhetorical point, of course, but when it comes to Romney's falsehoods, I'm not sure whose record he twists more, either. Maybe you can help me decide by taking a look at the 19th installment of my weekly series, chronicling Mitt's mendacity.

1. In an interview with Mark Halperin, Romney argued about President Obama, "Did he hold unemployment below 8%? It's been, what, 39 months now. That hasn't happened. He promised it would happen by virtue of his stimulus."

As Romney surely knows by now, that's simply not true.

2. In the same interview, Romney asked, "Are people happy with ... the level of foreclosures?"

Romney was trying to attack the administration, but he's on record supporting more foreclosures, making this, at a minimum, wildly misleading.

3. Romney added, in reference to the president, " Look at him right now. He just doesn't have a clue what to do to get this economy going. I do."

Actually, Obama's jobs agenda, unveiled in September, included specific policy proposals thatRomney had previously endorsed. If the president "doesn't have a clue," then Romney doesn't have a clue.

4. Romney went on to say, "I actually lay out a plan to get us to a balanced budget within eight years."

That's plainly false. Romney says his plan "can't be scored," but independent budget analysts have found his agenda would make the deficit bigger, not smaller, and add trillions to the national debt.

5. Romney also argued, in the context of talking about budget savings, "I'm going to take action immediately by eliminating programs like Obamacare, which become more and more expensive down the road -- by eliminating them, we get to a balanced budget."

He's lying. In fact, this is the polar opposite of the truth -- Obamacare's savings become greater in future years, and killing the law makes it harder to balance the budget.

6. Romney said, in addressing likely budget cuts, " I'd like my grandkids to be able to watch PBS. But I'm not willing to borrow money from China."

The implication here is that U.S. debt is financed by the Chinese. This isn't true -- China only holds about 8% of the nation's debt.

7. On taxes, Romney argued, "I'm not looking to lower the tax burden paid by the highest-income Americans. That's a fundamental principle."

That's a fundamental falsehood. Romney's plan slashes taxes on the wealthy.

8. On a related note, he added, "I'm looking, if there's any break at all, the break will go to middle-income Americans that have been most hurt by the Obama economy."

In reality, it's the rich, not the middle class, that primarily benefits from Romney's tax plan.

9. In a speech in Washington, Romney insisted, "President Obama has decided to attack success."

The Romney campaign has never been able to point to a single credible example of Obama attacking success.

10. In the same speech, Romney added, "When the President took office ... he faced a spending crisis. It's only gotten worse."

There is no universe in which this is even close to being true.

11. In making the case against Obama's student-loan reforms, the Romney campaign said it intends to "reverse President Obama's nationalization of the student loan market."

This is demonstrably false -- the market wasn't nationalized. Since all kinds of private-sector banks still make all kinds of student loans, the argument doesn't even make sense.

12. Romney told Fox News that "it certainly sounds like" the president is, as Rush Limbaugh put it, "running against capitalism." Romney added, "There's no question but that he's attacking capitalism."

No sensible person could possibly believe this is true, and neither Romney nor his aides have ever provided an example of the president attacking capitalism. Obama routinely does the opposite.

13. Romney argued in an op-ed that Obama "signed into law a budget scheme that threatens to saddle the U.S. military with nearly $1 trillion in cuts over the next 10 years," which the president's own Defense Secretary criticized.

That's not even close to being accurate.

14. Referencing Noam Scheiber's book, The Escape Artists, Romney argued, "In this book, [White House officials] point out that they said the American people will forget how long the recovery took. So that means they went into this knowing that when they passed Obamacare, it was going to make life harder for the American people."

That's not really what the book says, and it's not what the president's team argued.

15. Romney boasted this week, in a rare reference to his one term as governor, "[W]e didn't just slow the rate of growth of our government, we actually cut it."

No, you didn't.

16. The Romney campaign also argued this week that Romney created "well in excess of 100,000" jobs as an executive at Bain Capital.

You've got to be kidding me.

Previous editions of Chronicling Mitt's Mendacity: Vol. IIIIIIIVVVIVIIVIIIIXXXIXII,XIIIXIVXVXVIXVIIXVIII

The Big Lies of Mitt Romney III: Obama Has No Jobs Plan

BOBBLEMITTAlexWong:Getty

classic of total disingenuous crap:

“[W]ith America in crisis, with 23 million people out of work or stopped looking for work, he hasn’t put forth a plan to get us working again. Now I know we’re getting close to an election so he’ll come out with one soon, but three and a half years later, we’re waiting.”

Funny, but I remember the stimulus and the auto-bailout and continuation of TARP. And then I recall Obama coming out storming in January with a State of the Union address that demanded quick passage of his American Jobs Act. This is presumably what Romney isreferring to later in the same mass of lies:

“[h]e blames Congress, he goes after Congress, but we remember the president’s own party had a super majority in both houses for his first two years, so you can hardly blame Congress for the faults that he’s put in place himself, and so he’s casting about looking for someone to blame and just hasn’t been able to find anybody — whether it’s the ATM machines or the tsunami or Europe.”

But Obama has blamed Congress for not acting on his jobs bill, as Jed Lewison notes. There is a perfect symmetry here for Romney: he attacks Obama's successful jobs program then claims it doesn't exist. I guess he's counted on a full-bore amnesiac scenario in which the US economy was fine and its budget balanced until Obama came along and meretriciously added on a pile of more debt and spending for some reason - with no results on employment. That is the universe his political psyche now lives in - and it is a total untruth. Sargent summarizes:

Romney’s calculation: Voters will not care if Obama had a job plan that was blocked by the opposition; voters only care about results; not being able to get your plan passed despite determined opposition is tantamount to not having a plan or not acting at all; it’s time to elect someone who will be able to get something done.

And you know what? Romney may be right.

I think this is a core goal of the total obstructionists in the GOP: to prevent Obama from doing anything past his first two years to alleviate the sluggish recovery, so they can then blame the subsequent sluggishness on him, and then cover the whole cake in surreal, deceptive, cynical Rovian icing. It may work. Which is why we need to do what we can to expose the lies as insistently as we can.

 Big Lie I here. Big Lie II here.

(Photo: Alex Wong/Getty.)

RSS

© 2013   Created by Atheist Universe.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service