Feedback and Notes

 No Gods or Scumps Allowed

Latest Activity

Stephen commented on Doone's group Humans of Earth and a Grotesque Idiot News
"(In my own opinion, for what it's worth, I would much prefer to give up Trident missiles and…"
3 hours ago
Doone commented on Doone's group Humans of Earth and a Grotesque Idiot News
"Sorry, it is obviously a penguin and not a pelican.  Oddly, i see pelicans all of the time but…"
7 hours ago
Mrs.B commented on Doone's group Humans of Earth and a Grotesque Idiot News
"Too cute to be related to scum......"
7 hours ago
Stephen commented on Doone's group Humans of Earth and a Grotesque Idiot News
" Penguin "
7 hours ago
Clayton Rhofes commented on Kathleen Judy's blog post A Brief Introduction To Wikipedia And The Wikipedia Community
"I love how someone loves wikipedia. I like open-source software,which means people write software…"
12 hours ago
Doone commented on A Former Member's group The Burgeoning Family Tree of Monkey Men and Women
"Brain shape evolved gradually within the H. sapiens lineage, reaching present-day human variation…"
13 hours ago
Doone commented on Doone's group Humans of Earth and a Grotesque Idiot News
"Scump's relatives are much nicer than him.  Here is one feeding a fish to a Pelican"
19 hours ago
Doone commented on A Former Member's group Animal | Vegetable | Mineral | Fungus or Burgeoning Cockwombles
"A young orangutan feeding fish to a penguin. (Photo: rexfeatures)"
19 hours ago
Stephen commented on Adriana's group Freethought and Funny Bones
"Oh no just found out she's a Canadian Gal comedian."
21 hours ago
Stephen commented on Adriana's group Freethought and Funny Bones
"It says Betty Bowers is played by Deven Green. Does that mean that this Gal is a Guy?"
21 hours ago
Mrs.B commented on Adriana's group Freethought and Funny Bones
21 hours ago
Stephen commented on Hope's group Imagine No Organized Religion, Please! Looking better in 2020!
yesterday
Doone commented on Doone's group Humans of Earth and a Grotesque Idiot News
"Andrea Junker @Strandjunker · 4h Take Nixon, add pedophilia, add child concentration…"
yesterday
Doone commented on Doone's group Humans of Earth and a Grotesque Idiot News
"Last week an intelligence official named Shelby Pierson gave a classified briefing to the House…"
yesterday
Doone commented on Doone's group Humans of Earth and a Grotesque Idiot News
"Trending on Twitter THE AMERICAN PEOPLE ARE PROUD TO FINALLY HAVE A PRESIDENT THAT PUTS THE…"
yesterday
Mrs.B left a comment for Kathleen Judy
"Good to see you."
yesterday
Mrs.B left a comment for tyler jordan bonneau
"Good to see you."
yesterday
Kathleen Judy posted a blog post
yesterday
Stephen left a comment for Imagine No Religion
"Happy Birthday Imagine No Religion have a great day"
yesterday
Stephen commented on Doone's group Humans of Earth and a Grotesque Idiot News
"Shadowy Church Is at Center of Coronavirus Outbreak in South Korea SEOUL, South Korea — At…"
yesterday

We are a worldwide social network of freethinkers, atheists, agnostics and secular humanists.

I confess to my love for octopuses. They have fascinating behavior and adaptation, they behave so vertebrate-like. It's hard to forget we are looking st a mollusk, an animal that shares ancestors with slugs and snails. This new article from The Scientist highlights a collaboration between a marine biologist and a philosopher (yes, a philosopher) from the City University of New York, Peter Godfrey-Smith, who became fascinated by octopus behavior while vacationing in his native Australia. Octopuses have a nervous system that appears intermediate between other invertebrates and vertebrates: they have the ladderlike system and connecting knots seen in invertebrates, but also a brain similar to that found in vertebrates, in addition to hundreds of millions of neurons innervating their arms. Adaptation pushed them to evolve cognitive abilities similar to those of vertebrates. I think it's very interesting that a multidisciplinary team is studying cephalopod cognition. One of the questions they are trying to answer is whether their way of learning differs from that of vertebrates and whether the architecture of the nervous system has any bearing on that. For example, does the decentralization of neurons mean that cephalopods have multiple minds? People who study octopuses have observed that it seems as if each arm engages in independent exploration.

 

Octophilosophy

When it comes to studying cephalopod brains and behavior, it helps to have a philosopher around.

By Katherine Bagley | August 31, 2011

Calling octopuses intelligent beings might seem like a stretch. After all, the eight-armed invertebrates count the everyday garden snail among their close evolutionary cousins. But octopuses are experts in camouflage, can deter predators with poisonous bites, engage in play, solve complex problems, and can squeeze themselves into tiny crevices when threatened. Such observations indicate that the octopus is without a doubt smarter than the average snail, but the nature of this intelligence remains unknown. Considering that our branches on the evolutionary tree are separated by more than half a billion years, can the intellect of an octopus bear any comparison to that of a human? City University of New York philosopher Peter Godfrey-Smith has begun a unique collaboration with a team of Australian marine scientists to examine this distinctly philosophical question using biological research.

Godfrey-Smith spends nearly every summer in his native Sydney. His love of diving in the city’s harbor bore scientific fruit when he captured a rare photograph of gloomy octopuses (Octopus tetricus) mating and published his observations of the event in a short paper with marine biologist Christine Huffard of Conservation International Indonesia (Moll Res, 30:81-86, 2010). Godfrey-Smith started teaching himself about octopus biology, focusing on their nervous systems and brains.

Most invertebrates have ladderlike nervous systems with knots of neurons connected by nerve fibers. Vertebrate nervous systems are instead dominated by one big clump of neurons—the brain. Octopuses, along with their cephalopod cousins squid and cuttlefish, seem to be an evolutionary in-between. Their nervous system retains some knot architecture—more than half of their 500 million neurons are distributed throughout their eight arms—but they also have a large central brain.

 

Read the rest here.

Views: 741

Replies to This Discussion

Did he name his gloomy octopus Socrates?

:-) Looks more like Foucault to me :-)

ON BEING AN OCTOPUS

Godfrey-Smith_header

Peter Godfrey-Smith in Boston Review:

If octopuses did not exist, it would be necessary to invent them. I don’t know if we could manage this, so it’s as well that we don’t have to. As we explore the relations between mind, body, evolution, and experience, nothing stretches our thinking the way an octopus does.

In a famous 1974 paper, the philosopher Thomas Nagel asked: What is it like to be a bat? He asked this in part to challenge materialism, the view that everything that goes on in our universe comprises physical processes and nothing more. A materialist view of the mind, Nagel said, cannot even begin to give an explanation of the subjective side of our mental lives, an account of what it feels like to have thoughts and experiences. Nagel chose bats as his example because they are not so simple that we doubt they have experiences at all, but they are, he said, “a fundamentally alien form of life.”

Bats certainly live lives different from our own, but evolutionarily speaking they are our close cousins, fellow mammals with nervous systems built on a similar plan. If we want to think about something more truly alien, the octopus is ideal. Octopuses are distant from us in evolutionary terms, have a nervous system of very different design, and bodies with no bones and little fixed shape at all. What is it like to be an octopus? The question is intrinsically interesting and, beyond that, provides a good way to chip away at the problem Nagel raised for a materialist understanding of the mind.

Posted by Robin Varghese at 01:18 AM | Permalink

RSS

© 2020   Created by Atheist Universe.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service